Sunny's bookshelf
Sunny's bookshelf photo by Judy Solomon

Online book reviews since 2011, the very best in reviewing – connecting good readers with equally good writers

MAGPIE MURDERS

The Magpie Murders is Deliciously British! Anthony Horowitz’s mystery is set in a circumscribed Somerset village populated by a quarrelsome set of eccentric miscreants. The novel opens with a funeral witnessed by seven magpies. Spying the birds, one of the mourners recalls an old nursery rhyme: “Seven for a secret,/ Never to be told.” And so multiple secrets begin to unfold.

Ostensibly, Magpie Murders is the ninth in a fictional series written by Alan Conway and featuring Atticus Pund, who acts as if he had just stepped out of a novel by Agatha Christie or Dorothy Sayers or P. D. James. Deliciously British, indeed, when a second sudden death occurs in the same Saxby-on-Avon manor house, and Atticus Pűnd is called upon to assist the police with their investigations. Conway’s Magpie Murders turns out to be a manuscript inside the pages of Horowitz’s novel, Magpie Murders.

Alongside the reader, Conway’s editor Susan Ryeland is reading, too. And much to her surprise, and mine, the final pages are missing. Just when Pűnd is ready to reveal whodunnit, the manuscript ends. So, Susan Ryeland must solve the mystery of the lost pages before Cloverleaf Books can publish their best-selling author’s latest rendition of Atticus Pűnd. Finding those pages turns out to be no easy feat, however, because almost immediately, the fictional author Alan Conway dies under mysterious circumstances. Whodunnit? That’s what Susan now must discover, in parallel with her search for the manuscript’s finale.

The first half of Magpie Murders is Conway’s Magpie Murders; the second half is Susan’s search.

As you well might imagine, Susan’s investigation parallels more than her quest for the missing pages. It also assumes overtones of Pund’s inquiries. Many of the people Susan encounters remind her of characters in the Pűnd novels. Before long, the reader sees the associations, too. The overall effect is ratiocination at its very best. I not only enjoyed Susan’s logic, but I loved her comments about the art of writing effective mystery series. Along with her investigations, we hear a continuous riff on authors and editors and the all-consuming writing process. Anyone who enjoys a good British mystery will truly appreciate Susan’s observations and the way they reflect and reinforce the problems she is trying to solve.

In many ways, Horowitz’s novel is a genuine tour de force. The framing is ingenious, the asides provocative, and the mysteries themselves astutely complex. The echoes and reverberations, both obvious and subtle, are never awkward or heavy-handed. I’m happy to see that a sequel with similar complexities is in the offing. Moonflower Murders is scheduled for publication in November 2020. Apparently, it, too, will embroil Susan Ryeland in another plot that echoes a different Alan Conway/Atticus Pűnd mystery. I expect Moonflower Murders will have just as many witty asides and just as much British appeal. Magpie Murders deserves real accolades for a mystery well done. I recommend it highly, very highly. What a fun, fun esoteric, and delicious read!  – Ann Ronald

Also available by Anthony Horowitz: Alex Rider series 12 books; Susan Ryeland series 2 books; The Power of Five Series 5 books; Horowitz’s Holmes Series 2 books; Detective Daniel Hawthorne Series 2 books; Diamond Brothers Series 7 books; Horowitz Horror Shorts Series 6 books; Legends series 6 books; Pentagram Chronicles series 4 books; Stormbreaker: The Movie 2 books;

Bookin’ with Sunny strongly supports Independent Bookstores and Public Libraries.

Add your thoughts and comments...

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Support local booksellers, buy Magpie Murders at Bookshop

Bookshop offers low prices and has a mission to financially support local, independent bookstores and book sellers like Bookin’ with Sunny. We receive a commission on orders placed through our links to Bookshop – thank you.

Recent BWS Reviews

About the Reviewer

Sign up for reviews by email

You’ll get email updates from Bookin’ with Sunny when we add a new review or blog post, and we never share your email with anyone else.