Sunny's bookshelf
Sunny's bookshelf photo by Judy Solomon

Online book reviews since 2011, the very best in reviewing – connecting good readers with equally good writers

The Fifth Petal – Witchcraft Revisited

Sign up to receive our latest reviews by email


Brunonia Barry is another contemporary author who can deftly embroider three narratives into a single story. The Fifth Petal takes place during three different time periods—the Salem witch trials of 1692, three Halloween murders in 1989, and another sudden death in 2014. In this novel, Rafferty, the Salem chief of police, not only starts investigating the 2014 occasion but also begins to piece together threads that will tie these three disparate moments together.

The focal point is Halloween and Salem witchcraft throughout the centuries. All three young women murdered in 1989 were descendants of the condemned witches hung in the past. When killed, they were exorcising their ancestors and the past. The young daughter of one of them, Callie, hid in the bushes when her mother and two friends died. Traumatized, she hasn’t been back to Salem for a quarter of a century. But when Callie reads about the 2014 death, she learns that Rose, her youthful mentor and a woman often accused of the 1989 murders, is still alive and now is being questioned about the most recent Salem mystery.

Thus, Callie returns to Salem and joins forces with Rafferty to determine what actually happened on that fateful Halloween in 1989. Several ingredients bring life to their search for the truth. One is almost mystic, as Barry probes the boundaries of white witchcraft and black witchcraft. Might the occult be blamed for Callie’s mother’s death? Barry tiptoes around the supernatural, but never allows mysticism to vanquish either truth or storytelling. I, who am normally suspicious of the paranormal and who tries never to read books that deal with witches and banshees, found The Fifth Petal quite logical and persuasive. Barry does an excellent job of going far enough but not too far.

Another related facet of this work of fiction is its discussion of healing. Callie is trained as a musical healer, a woman who uses music as a cancer palliative and singing bowls as psychological therapy. Rafferty’s wife Towner is a healer, too, a woman whose teas ease pain. And the matriarch of Towner’s family rules Yellow Dog Island, a shelter for abused women where battered wives and children can retreat into safety. Even the local witch, Ann, uses her gifts to cure people, not to harm them. That said, let me emphasize what I wrote in the preceding paragraph. The Fifth Petal is not a book of esoteric witchcraft or of shades of the occult. Rather, it dances around the edges of mystery while solving the real-life mysterious occasions of the Salem deaths.

In sum, I would say that The Fifth Petal is another one of those novels that “Bookin’ with Sunny” has gifted to me. I probably would not have bought it on my own, but when it appeared on my stack of Sunny books I picked it up, read the first few pages, and was hooked. From beginning to end, The Fifth Petal is a good read. The finale is fitting, too. Barry finishes her narrative tapestry with convincing chaos that makes solid sense. I finished the book with the comfort of closure, a mystery solved, and (like any good piece of detective fiction) villains brought to justice. – Ann Ronald

Also available by Brunonia Barry: The Lace Reader, The Map of True Places.

2 Responses

  1. Ann, I just finished this book and found it captivating. Part of that is the tuning into energy levels of the various characters from Callie to Ann to Towner. And Callie’s healing is very beautiful – I have heard various bowls like the ones she uses. They are extremely soothing or healing so to have this element in the book was very real to me. These womoon come from a long line of independent, courageous, and smart ancestors – therefore they were “witches” to be feared, especially in the patriarchal world that was early America, to say nothing of what’s things today.
    So yes, it is a good read and thoughtful one.

Add your thoughts and comments...

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Share this Review

Related Reviews

Not Weakness, Navigating the Culture of Chronic Pain

Not Weakness

Not Weakness, Navigating the Culture of Chronic Pain – Francesca Grossman’s book is more than memoir or self-help. It is an honest exploration of the

Read More »
Dreamers of the Day

Dreamers of the Day

Dreamers of the Day is Mary Doria Russell’s novel that is as fresh if not fresher today than when first published in 2008. Mary Doria Russell’s

Read More »

The God of  Endings

Jacqueline Hollands’s debut novel, The God of  Endings, reveals the loneliness of the life of an unwilling vampire. Jacqueline Holland’s debut novel, The God of Endings, follows

Read More »

About the Reviewer

Sign up for reviews by email

You’ll get email updates from Bookin’ with Sunny when we add a new review or blog post, and we never share your email with anyone else.

Shopping in-store Fun!

Support your local community’s economic growth by shopping for books at your independent bookstore in person, online at their website, or by phone.