Sunny's bookshelf
Sunny's bookshelf photo by Judy Solomon

Online book reviews since 2011, the very best in reviewing – connecting good readers with equally good writers

Doc, A Novel

Sign up to receive our latest reviews by email


John Henry “Doc” Holliday: Southern landed gentry, classical pianist, consumptive, classicist, dentist, gambler, alcoholic, loyal friend, detective, and horseman.  In Russell’s fictional version, Doc Holliday is many things but he is not a gunslinger.  She ends the story on the eve of him and the Earp brothers leaving Dodge City, Kansas in 1879 and heading off to Tombstone, Arizona Territory, the O.K .Corral, and history.  Personally, I would like to have read her interpretation of the thirty-second shoot-out at the famous corral.  She wrote the book she wanted to write, however, not the one I would have preferred.  That’s as it should be.  Will she write a sequel?

Still, the story Russell tells, solid historical fiction, is compelling even without the myth-making O.K. Corral climax.  Doc Holiday is the main character, but there are other real historical persons of interest in the novel.  Russell digs into them with relish and some apt imagination.  They come alive. There is Kate, the working whore who prodded Doc to leave Texas for Dodge.  She is not exactly the whore with a heart of gold, but gold figures prominently in her daily calculations.  Nor is she the antiseptic “Miss Kitty” of Gunsmoke fame.  Kate is a fully sexualized being who plies her trade while living with and loving Doc.  Then there are the Earp brothers whom Doc befriends.  James and his wife, a former hooker, run a brothel in Dodge City.  Wyatt is a puritanically inclined some-time deputy marshal, sometime faro dealer, who insists on enforcing the law equally against the rich and the poor, the powerful and the feckless.  Morgan is something of kindred spirit to Doc, sharing Doc’s passion for ideas, culture, and good books if on a slightly lower evolutionary plane.  A delightful character is Alexander von Angensperg a Jesuit from Wichita.  Austrian and well-educated—typical of the Jesuits—Father Angensperg also provides some cultural and spiritual nourishment to Doc as well as being a source of helpful information about the murder victim.  Incidentally, in this story Father Angensperg helped found Wichita’s St. Francis hospital, my birthplace.

Did I mention that this novel also contains a murder mystery?  A young, talented black man is found dead in the smoking remains of a Dodge City livery stable.  His death is ruled accidental, but over time Doc and Morgan Earp begin to think otherwise. The murder’s discovery and solution provide Russell with a slender thread to cinch-up the welter of tangled events and themes. Even so the novel is more character than plot driven.

As a result, Russell’s novel appears headed towards chaos at times. There is so much energy being flung-off around Dodge City.  The restless, repressed cowboys arrive regularly to hand-off their trail herds of cattle to the railroads.  There are deputies nervously forcing the cowboys to check their shootin’ irons at the city limits.  Boot Hill provides mute but graphic testimony to Dodge City’s culture of casual blood sports. Ironically, the town’s business plan is “don’t kill the customers.”  Gambling, drinking, whoring, brawling, and laudanum are taken for granted although the nascent prohibition campaign is beginning to have an effect.  Dodge City’s rambunctiousness—chaos moving incrementally towards entropy—is a minor theme that Russell deftly weaves into Doc.

Doc Holliday is a prime example of Dodge City’s trajectory—arcing towards entropy(death).  Doc is so many things, mostly good, some bad, but always in the background is his tuberculosis and the inevitability of his foreshortened life.  He is never maudlin about his malady.  Instead, Doc seizes days, hours, and minutes in a frenzied attempt to cram a full life into a half one.  In so doing he drinks too much, eats too little, and burns his candles at both ends and in the middle.  Still, Doc’s journey as a Southern boy who happens to be a race-blind, chivalric knight-errant, however entertaining, is a bit unconvincing to me, a Kansas abolitionist.  This novel is a worthy successor to her A Thread of Grace.   – Neal Ferguson

Also available by Mary Doria Russell: Epitaph (coming in 2015, which should make Neal Ferguson a happy reviewer); Dreamers of the Day, A Thread of Grace; Children of God; The Sparrow.  – Solomon


3 Responses

  1. Since my parents hale from Kansas, albeit northeastern, the sense of the place is very familiar to me from them talking about it – especially the weather! My Dad hated it and the brutal winters.
    But Neal I did not want this book to end. The character development was tremendous with historical background to round out the denizens of Dodge at this stage of its development. The way issues were handled seemed very real to me and the Council meeting while playing poker brought back memories of my parents playing poker and milking cows!
    I loved Kate and the Jesuit – how real they seemed and Doc – well, you are right, he tried to live every minute he could down to the last minute. Doc comes so clearly into focus that one keeps hoping there will be a cure. The rough and tumble characters all fill a wonderful read.

    1. Great to hear from you Donna, I’m going to pass this on to Neal. I just told him that she’s already written the book on the OK Corral and he’s waiting to get his advance copy of that one!

  2. We are in agreement about not wanting the book to end. We read Doc in our couples’ book club (25 years and counting). A major complaint was that it should have included the OK Corral debacle. While I agree in part, I also liked the long back story in post-Civil War in Kansas, at a time when parts of Kansas were still very much a part of the frontier. Civilization was coming slowly and unevenly. Kate and Father Angensperg, SJ, are particularly appealing to me. The Jesuit would make for an interesting piece of historical fiction.

    Sunny has told me that Russell is doing a sequel, but I have no idea when it will be published. My pen is poised.

    Speaking of Kansas. I’m going to a Kansas Birthday party this weekend to celebrate Kansas admission day, January 31. You can take the boy out of Kansas (thank God), but . . . .

Add your thoughts and comments...

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Share this Review

Related Reviews

Dreamers of the Day

Dreamers of the Day

Dreamers of the Day is Mary Doria Russell’s novel that is as fresh if not fresher today than when first published in 2008. Mary Doria Russell’s

Read More »

About the Reviewer

Sign up for reviews by email

You’ll get email updates from Bookin’ with Sunny when we add a new review or blog post, and we never share your email with anyone else.

Shopping in-store Fun!

Support your local community’s economic growth by shopping for books at your independent bookstore in person, online at their website, or by phone.