Sunny's bookshelf
Sunny's bookshelf photo by Judy Solomon

Online book reviews since 2011, the very best in reviewing – connecting good readers with equally good writers

The Grande Dame and Hitler’s Twin

A Comedy of Errors and more.

Sally Patterson Tubach subtitled her novel “A Comedy of Errors.” In truth, The Grande Dame and Hitler’s Twin is a hilarity of errors, a madcap romp conducted by countless eccentric and egocentric characters. All the while, they’re capering through a sea of allusions—to music, to the visual arts, and, most of all, to literature. Widely educated readers will be thoroughly amused by Tubach’s concoction, will love to join this bizarre array of men and women and to puzzle through the esoteric hints that appear on nearly every page.

The Grande Dame and Hitler’s Twin actually divides itself into two distinct sections. The first features Myrtle Halstead, an elderly well-to-do woman who has recently moved into an elite San Francisco retirement high rise. The second focuses on Jean-Louis Lamour, a fictional twin of Adolf Hitler, who languished in glacial ice for generations until his cold, perfectly-preserved body is found, thawed, and resuscitated. The connective tissue between Myrtle and Jean-Louis is Bruno de Carlo, an Italian American who buys Myrtle’s Russian Hill residence and who, decades later, is tasked by the CIA to look after the unacknowledged twin. Bruno’s partner, an East German named Hermann Wittgenstein, plays an overarching role, too, first as Myrtle and Bruno’s handyman, later as an overseer of Jean-Louis.

And these four characters are only the tip of the iceberg! Their adventures are accompanied by a host of extraordinary individuals. Tubach has a genuine knack for zeroing on what is unique about a person. As I read, I was reminded of what I once learned about Charles Dickens and what are labeled his “grotesques.” When he met someone, he would often center his attention on a single feature—eyebrows, hairstyle, a bloated stomach, an awkward posture—until that someone actually became that feature in Dickens’ imagination. That’s how he created his odd and “grotesque” characters. Think plumping up the old grandfather Smallweed, for example, or Miss Havisham in her tattered gown. That is how Tubach individualizes her peculiar characters, too, by isolating one or two traits that before long actually become the person him or herself.

Jack Peterson, for example, another elderly resident who, inspired by Myrtle and a Thomas Mann book club conversation, writes his own bestsellers, beginning with Resurrection in Venice. His popular but shallow books are based on what he can spy through a telescope set up on his apartment balcony.  Then there is Crystal Beatty, a wealthy heiress who romantically pursues Bruno for decades, through the grande dame pages and on into the Hitler’s twin pages, her unkempt hair continuously wafting in the wind. Black Donald, drug dealer and chauffeur and man of all traits. Gloria Majestic, the ever-helpful television personality who grows enamored of the elderly retirement community residents. Or Latrone Sanders, the neurotic CIA agent whose anxiety about flying and boating makes trailing Jean-Louis a task fraught with fear. That his mother was Myrtle’s favorite nurse adds another twist to the plot.

Well, you get the idea. These are not your ordinary people populating an everyday comedy of errors. And I haven’t even touched on the hilariously convoluted plot with its countless artistic allusions, the mistaken identities, the unexpected storyline twists, the implausible encounters. I read this book and constantly shook my head at its madness. But I did so with a smile on my face. So I recommend The Grande Dame and Hitler’s Twin to those readers who enjoy a good laugh. And who relish solving literary, musical, and artistic puzzles. And who want to savor a book that’s just plain fun.  – Ann Ronald

Also available by Sally Tubach: An Uncommon Friendship; German Voices; It Isn’t a Bus.

2 Responses

  1. So happy readers will experience Sally’s wonderful sense of humor she brings to her writings.

Add your thoughts and comments...

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Shopping in-store is back!

Support your local community’s economic growth by shopping for books
at your independent bookstore in person, online at their website, or by phone.

Recent BWS Reviews

About the Reviewer

Sign up for reviews by email

You’ll get email updates from Bookin’ with Sunny when we add a new review or blog post, and we never share your email with anyone else.

Skip to content