Sunny's bookshelf
Sunny's bookshelf photo by Judy Solomon

Online book reviews since 2011, the very best in reviewing – connecting good readers with equally good writers


Emma Donoghue has concocted a collection of short stories that consider a single innovative theme. Astray features a diverse set of characters who have done just that, gone astray, in one way or another. Some have strayed from one locale to another; others have strayed socially, a few have strayed from their core beliefs. The Table of Contents sets up Astray’s organizing principle. The first four stories belong in a category called “Departures;” the next five, “In Transit;” and the final five, “Arrivals and Aftermaths.” The stories themselves are wildly disparate, taking place around the globe and often in centuries gone by. But they are united by their theme—men and women on the move, unfortunately so.

Another element that unites Donoghue’s stories is the fact that she has developed each one from a grain of truth. At the end of each story, with further elaboration at Astray’s end, Donoghue reveals the source of her inspiration. Sometimes it’s only a line-item in a newspaper, sometimes a piece of correspondence, sometimes an artistic life well-lived that Donoghue uses to extrapolate a single experience. A pair of Canadian sculptors, two women who shared their lives for decades, Donoghue imagines shuttered in a nursing home, enfeebled and no longer able to communicate. Or she creates the diary of a Puritan settler who tattles on witches to his community, condemning the women he accuses while ruining his own life as well.

Astray begins with Jumbo the elephant, sold to P. T. Barnum as a circus attraction and about to be shipped to North America. Jumbo’s distraught keeper leads them both astray. Another ocean crossing in another Astray story features Jane, sailing with her two children from Belfast to Quebec to meet her husband. William journeyed to Canada the year before, hoping to find work. Instead, cholera found him, and Jane’s arrival will coincide with his death, a poignant straying unlike most of the other stories in Donoghue’s collection. In fact, many of the strayings come from sexual impulses. One of my favorites delves into the feelings of a young New Yorker, is “Daddy’s Girl.” After the death of her beloved father, Imelda Hall learns he was always a woman disguised as a man. Who is led astray? The father or the daughter? Donoghue leaves the answer to the reader to decide.

This is true of all the Astray stories. Donoghue writes in a straightforward style, making no judgments whatsoever. She doesn’t waste words, and she doesn’t embroider the facts. Rather, she crafts a pithy anecdote, expanding a moment or two in time into a lived fictional experience. Since it only takes her a few pages to isolate a heartfelt situation, her stories are short. And, as I mentioned earlier, it is up to the reader to interiorize authorial intent. For two reasons, then, a reader will enjoy Donoghue’s fine collection. Her stories are keenly fashioned; her thematic continuity is a deep connective tissue that threads through every page. Astray, in sum, is a successful artistic package designed by a very talented Irish-Canadian author.  – Ann Ronald

Also available by Emma Donoghue: Room; The Wonder; Frog Music; Slammerkin; The Sealed Letter; Life Mask; Astray; The Lotterys Plus One; Kissing the Witch, Old Tales in New Salem; Landing; Touchy Subjects; Food; Stir-Fry; The Woman Who Gave Birth to Rabbits; Passions Between Women; Three and a Half Deaths; We Are Michael Field; Poems Between Women, Four Centuries of Love, Romantic Friendship, and Desire; Akin; Selected Plays; Signatories; Ladies Night at Finbar’s Hotel; Since I First Saw Your Face; Ladies and Gentlemen, A Play; Lesbian Love Stories; Soba: roman.

Bookin’ with Sunny strongly supports Independent Bookstores and Public Libraries.


Add your thoughts and comments...

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Share this Review

Related Reviews

My Beloved World

My Beloved World

Sonia Sotomayor, Associate Supreme Court Justice, brings the breadth and depth of her lived experiences to her memoir, My Beloved World. Supreme Court Associate Justice Sonia

Read More »
I alone can fix it

I Alone Can Fix It

I Alone Can Fix It – Donald J. Trump’s Catastrophic Final Year. Carol Leonnig and Philip Rucker’s investigative journalism might have been titled, Duck Dynasty &

Read More »

About the Reviewer

Sign up for reviews by email

You’ll get email updates from Bookin’ with Sunny when we add a new review or blog post, and we never share your email with anyone else.

Shopping in-store is back!

Support your local community’s economic growth by shopping for books at your independent bookstore in person, online at their website, or by phone.